> I think that I would be a little more specific. As
Tolkein often mentions
> that the Elves who saw the light of Valinor are
the fairest and most
skilled
> of the children of Illuvatar, I would probably
pick Celeborn, 'cause he
> wakes up next to Galadriel.
>
> Winn
>
RD: Winn, that's the best answer I've sen yet!
Apart from my choice of
Sauron, because obviously, if Sauron won, he could
wake up next to any elven
babe(s) he fancied!
I think sauron could only eye the elven babes.
Since laurence could remember the name of the Sam's
dockey, he might be able to answer my question.
Didn't Celeborn and Galadriel spend some time apart
from each other ? I think it was the second age. They
were not yet ruling Lorien, since the previous ruler
had not yet had his 'accidental' drowning which
allowed Galadriel/Celeborn their takeover. I think the
war has split them apart, but I forget where they
were.
Richard.
-------------------------- eGroups Sponsor
Middle Earth PBM List - Harlequin Games
To Unsubscribe:www.onelist.com
_____________________________________________________________________________ http://clubs.yahoo.com.au - Yahoo! Clubs
- Join a club or build your own!
wrote: >
> > I think that I would be a little more specific. As
> Tolkein often mentions
> > that the Elves who saw the light of Valinor are
> the fairest and most
> skilled
> > of the children of Illuvatar, I would probably
> pick Celeborn, 'cause he
> > wakes up next to Galadriel.
> >
> > Winn
> >
> RD: Winn, that's the best answer I've sen yet!
> Apart from my choice of
> Sauron, because obviously, if Sauron won, he could
> wake up next to any elven
> babe(s) he fancied!
I think sauron could only eye the elven babes.
Since laurence could remember the name of the Sam's
dockey, he might be able to answer my question.
Didn't Celeborn and Galadriel spend some time apart
from each other ? I think it was the second age. They
were not yet ruling Lorien, since the previous ruler
had not yet had his 'accidental' drowning which
allowed Galadriel/Celeborn their takeover. I think the
war has split them apart, but I forget where they
were.
RD: You are right about the separation. Tolkien snr never did resolve this.
'Unfinished Tales' by JRR Tolkien (edited by his son Christopher Tolkien)
(Unwin paperback in UK) has a chapter 'on Celeborn and Galadriel' which
gives a few variant (and inconsistent) histories which were never resolved.
