This FA riddle is on the Wiki site and numerous different answers have been tried, with no success. It cannot be right that we have the best of the ME brains on this forum and we cant answer this riddle. So we need more brain power, please help
Could the answer be: Belegost ?
Before the extinguishing of the light
before the coming of the Darkest Dark
it arose as mighty sight
til the flood did render it start.
Failed answers: Almaren, Numenor, Hyarmentir, Ezehollar, Two Pillars, Utumno, Meneltarma, Tol Eressea, Avallone, Taniquetil, Thangorodrim.